Every brewer eventually tries to brew a beer they love. It's a great exercise because it forces you to think like a detective: what can you see, smell and taste, and what does each clue tell you about how the beer was made?

Step 1: gather everything you can

The label. ABV is always there. Some breweries list IBU, the malts, the hops, even the yeast. Read the can or bottle closely.

The brewery. Many breweries publish more detail on their websites and social media than on the label — hop varieties, malt bills, sometimes original gravity. A friendly email occasionally gets a surprisingly helpful reply. Some breweries even publish home-brew-scale versions of their recipes.

Published clone recipes. Books, magazines and brewing forums have clone recipes for many well-known beers. Treat them as starting points, not gospel; quality varies.

Style guidelines. If the beer is a fairly typical example of a style, the BJCP guidelines give you sensible ranges to work within.

Step 2: taste it like a brewer

Pour the beer into a clear glass and take notes.

  • Colour and clarity. Pale straw, gold, amber, brown, black? Bright or hazy?
  • Aroma. Citrus, tropical, pine, floral? Bready, caramel, roast? Fruity or spicy yeast character?
  • Flavour and balance. Sweet or dry? How bitter? Where does the bitterness sit?
  • Body and carbonation. Thin and crisp, or full and smooth? Lightly or highly carbonated?

Taste it alongside a couple of similar beers. Differences are easier to spot side by side than in isolation.

Step 3: work out the gravities

You know the ABV. Guess the final gravity from the style and how sweet or dry the beer tastes, then work back to the original gravity.

ABV ≈ (original gravity − final gravity) × 131.25

Example: a 5.2 percent pale ale that tastes fairly dry probably finishes around 1.010.

5.2 ÷ 131.25 = 0.040, so the original gravity is about 1.010 + 0.040 = 1.050.

A sweeter, fuller beer at the same ABV finishes higher, say 1.014, which needs an original gravity of about 1.054 and more crystal malt or a higher mash temperature.

Step 4: build the grist

Start with a base malt for most of the grist, then add specialty malts to match the colour and the malt flavour.

  • Bready, biscuity character suggests a British base malt like Maris Otter, or a little biscuit malt.
  • Caramel and toffee means crystal malt — lighter for honey and caramel, darker for raisin and toffee.
  • Coffee and chocolate means roasted malts.
  • A silky, full body with haze suggests oats or wheat.

Use your software to match the colour. Clones often fail on colour first, because it's the easiest thing to see.

Step 5: choose the hops

If the brewery names the hops, you're most of the way there. If not, match the aroma: tropical and passionfruit suggests Galaxy or similar; citrus and pine suggests classic American varieties; earthy and floral suggests English or noble-style hops. The substitution guide helps when the named hop isn't available.

Then match the bitterness — from the label if it's listed, or by taste otherwise — and put the hop timing where the aroma suggests. Big, fresh aroma means a lot of late and dry hops.

Step 6: get the yeast right

Yeast is often the hardest part of a clone, because many breweries use their own house strain.

  • Clean beers with no obvious fruit or spice are usually made with a neutral American-style ale strain or a lager strain.
  • Fruity, slightly mineral English character suggests an English strain.
  • Spice and fruit suggests Belgian or wheat beer strains.

Some bottle-conditioned beers carry live yeast that you can culture from the sediment in the bottle. Coopers' bottle-conditioned ales are the classic Australian example — generations of home brewers have grown their yeast from the dregs. Build it up slowly with a small starter, stepping up in size over several days.

Step 7: brew, then compare blind

When your clone is ready, buy a fresh example of the original and taste them side by side — ideally blind, with a friend pouring. Note every difference: colour, aroma, bitterness, sweetness, body.

Then change one thing and brew again. Most good clones take two to four attempts.

A clone notebook

Keep a page for every clone attempt, laid out so you can compare versions at a glance.

  • The target — the beer's name, ABV and any published numbers or ingredients.
  • Your recipe — grist, hops with timings, yeast, mash temperature and water.
  • What you measured — original and final gravity, and the ABV you actually achieved.
  • Side-by-side notes — colour, aroma, flavour, bitterness, body and carbonation, each marked "closer", "same" or "further".
  • The one change you'll make next time, and why.

After two or three rounds, the notebook shows you clearly which changes moved the beer towards the original and which didn't.

Matching colour by eye

Colour is the easiest thing to get wrong and the easiest to check. Pour the original and your clone into identical clear glasses and hold them against a white background in daylight. If yours is darker, cut back the darkest specialty malt first — a few grams of a dark malt changes colour far more than a few hundred grams of a light one. If it's lighter, add a touch of medium crystal or a very small amount of a debittered black malt, which adds colour with almost no flavour.

Why you'll never get it exact

Breweries have advantages a home brewer can't easily copy.

  • Freshness. You're comparing your fresh beer with one that may have spent weeks on a truck and a shelf — or a fresher version at the brewery tap.
  • Scale and process. Commercial fermenters are tall and pressurised, which changes how yeast behaves. Their water, filtration and carbonation are all precisely controlled.
  • Ingredients. They may use proprietary hop products, specific malt lots or a house yeast you can't get.

Aim for a beer that someone who loves the original would happily drink. That's a successful clone.

A word on sharing

Brewing a clone for yourself and your mates is part of the hobby. Selling it, or putting the brewery's name or branding on it, isn't. Keep it personal.

Where to start

Classic, widely available beers make the best first clones, because you can easily buy a fresh example to compare. Pick something fairly simple — a pale ale or an amber — rather than a complex Belgian or a heavily barrel-aged stout. And if you'd like help working out a grist or a hop schedule, bring the can in and we'll taste it with you.