Cheese making looks mysterious, but most fresh cheeses come down to a few simple steps: warm the milk, add a culture, set it with rennet, cut the curd, drain and salt. If you've ever held a mash at temperature, you can make cheese.

The milk

  • Full-cream supermarket milk works for most fresh cheeses.
  • Avoid UHT milk. Ultra-high-temperature treatment damages the proteins, and it won't form a proper curd.
  • Homogenised milk works, but add calcium chloride to help it set firmly.
  • Non-homogenised milk — often sold as "unhomogenised" or in glass bottles — gives a better curd if you can get it.

The equipment

  • A stainless steel pot of about 5 litres. Avoid aluminium.
  • An accurate thermometer — temperature matters as much in cheese as in beer.
  • A long knife or curd knife that reaches the bottom of the pot.
  • A slotted spoon, a colander and cheesecloth.
  • Cheese moulds for draining and shaping.
  • No-rinse sanitiser. The same sanitation rules as brewing apply.

The Mad Millie kits package the cultures, rennet, moulds and instructions for each cheese together, which is how most people start.

Feta: the best first cheese

Feta is forgiving, needs no press and no ageing, and is ready the next day.

  1. Warm 4 litres of milk to 32 °C, stirring gently.
  2. Add mesophilic culture as the sachet directs, stir, and leave it covered for 45 to 60 minutes. This is called ripening.
  3. Add calcium chloride if using homogenised milk, diluted in a little cool water.
  4. Add rennet, diluted in cool, non-chlorinated water, and stir gently for a minute.
  5. Leave it undisturbed for 45 to 60 minutes, holding the temperature, until the curd gives a clean break: push a knife in and lift, and the curd should split cleanly with clear whey filling the gap.
  6. Cut the curd into 1 to 2 cm cubes, with vertical cuts both ways, then angled cuts.
  7. Rest five minutes, then stir gently for about 20 minutes to firm the curds.
  8. Ladle the curds into moulds lined with cheesecloth and let them drain, turning them a few times over several hours.
  9. Cut into blocks, salt them and refrigerate overnight, then store in brine.

Halloumi: the one that squeaks

Halloumi starts much like feta. The difference is at the end.

  1. Make the curd as for feta, then press the curds firmly in a mould for an hour or so.
  2. Heat the whey you drained off to around 85 to 90 °C.
  3. Cut the pressed cheese into slabs and poach them in the hot whey until they float — usually 20 to 30 minutes.
  4. Drain, salt and sprinkle with dried mint if you like. Store in the fridge in light brine.

It's ready to fry the same day, and it really does squeak.

Mozzarella: the quick one

The quick method uses citric acid to acidify the milk directly, then rennet to set it. The curds are heated in hot water — around 60 °C — until they become stretchy, then pulled and folded until smooth and glossy. It takes practice to get the texture right, but even the attempts that don't stretch beautifully taste good. It's the cheese that turns most people into regulars.

Ricotta from the leftovers

The whey left from feta or halloumi still contains protein. Heat it to around 90 °C, add a little vinegar or citric acid, and fine curds rise to the surface. Scoop them into cheesecloth to drain. Fresh ricotta, from what would otherwise be poured away.

Yoghurt and kefir

Even simpler. For yoghurt, heat milk to about 85 °C, cool it to around 43 °C, add a yoghurt culture, and keep it warm for six to twelve hours. Kefir uses grains or a culture at room temperature. Both are a gentle introduction to working with cultures.

Temperature, again

On the South Coast in summer, a kitchen can run well above the temperatures cultures like. An esky with a hot water bottle — or a frozen one in summer — makes a simple incubator, exactly as it does for a fermenter.

Common problems

  • The milk won't set. UHT milk, too little rennet, rennet stored warm or out of date, or chlorinated water used to dilute the rennet.
  • Curds are soft and mushy. Homogenised milk without calcium chloride, or curd cut before a clean break.
  • Cheese is rubbery. Overheated or over-stirred curds.

A first cheese-making kit

  1. A stainless pot of about 5 litres and an accurate thermometer.
  2. Mesophilic culture, rennet and calcium chloride.
  3. A long knife or curd knife, a slotted spoon and cheesecloth.
  4. Cheese moulds for feta and halloumi.
  5. Full-cream milk that is not UHT.

Bring your questions in — the artisan shelf gets browsed slowly, and that's half the point.