Once you've brewed a few all grain batches, water stops being a mystery ingredient and starts being a dial you can turn. Soft water like Shoalhaven's is the ideal place to start, because you're adding minerals rather than fighting the ones already there.

Why soft water is the easy option

Building a profile means adding salts to reach target levels of six minerals. Adding is simple: weigh, stir, done. Removing minerals means reverse osmosis or dilution, which is why brewers in hard-water cities buy distilled water by the carton. Around Nowra you can skip that step. Treat the chlorine, and your tap water is already close to a clean slate.

The six numbers that matter

Calcium (Ca). Aim for 50 to 150 mg/L. It helps mash enzymes, lowers mash pH a little, helps yeast flocculate and improves clarity. This is the mineral soft water is short of.

Magnesium (Mg). 5 to 30 mg/L is plenty, and malt provides most of what yeast needs. Above about 40 it starts to taste sour-bitter, and in large amounts it has a well-known laxative effect.

Sodium (Na). Up to about 50 mg/L rounds out malt flavour. Above 100, and especially combined with high sulfate, it tastes harsh and salty.

Chloride (Cl). 50 to 150 mg/L gives a fuller, rounder, slightly sweeter impression. It's the mineral behind soft, juicy hazy IPAs and malty English beers.

Sulfate (SO₄). 50 to 300 mg/L or more. Sulfate dries the finish and sharpens hop bitterness. West coast IPAs often run 200 to 300. Past about 400 it gets minerally and harsh.

Bicarbonate (HCO₃), or alkalinity. This pushes mash pH up. You want very little for pale beers and some for dark ones. Soft water has little to begin with, which is why dark beers sometimes need a pinch of baking soda.

Sulfate and chloride work as a pair

Brewers talk about the sulfate-to-chloride ratio as a quick way to describe a profile's character.

  • Below about 0.7:1 — malt-forward, full, rounded.
  • Around 1:1 — balanced.
  • 2:1 to 3:1 — hop-forward, crisp.
  • Above 3:1 — very dry and bitter.

The ratio is a useful shorthand but not the whole story. 50 sulfate and 25 chloride has the same ratio as 300 and 150, and those two beers taste nothing alike. Set the absolute levels first, then check the ratio.

The four salts

These numbers are what one gram adds to 20 litres of water. To work out a different volume, multiply by 20 and divide by your volume.

Salt 1 g in 20 L adds Use it for
Gypsum (calcium sulfate) Ca 11.6, SO₄ 27.9 mg/L Hoppy, dry, crisp beers
Calcium chloride (dihydrate) Ca 13.6, Cl 24.1 mg/L Malty, full, hazy beers
Epsom salt (magnesium sulfate) Mg 4.9, SO₄ 19.5 mg/L Extra sulfate without extra calcium
Baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) Na 13.7, HCO₃ 36.3 mg/L Raising pH for dark beers

One catch with calcium chloride: it comes as flakes (the dihydrate, figures above) or as anhydrous granules, which are stronger — about Ca 18 and Cl 32 per gram in 20 litres. Check the pack, and keep it sealed. It pulls moisture out of the air and turns into a damp lump that weighs heavier than it is.

A worked example: pale ale

Say you're brewing a 23 litre brew-in-a-bag pale ale with 30 litres of total water. You want roughly calcium 100, sulfate 150 and chloride 50 mg/L.

Scale the table for 30 litres first. One gram of gypsum in 30 litres adds Ca 7.8 and SO₄ 18.6. One gram of calcium chloride adds Ca 9.1 and Cl 16.1.

Sulfate first. 150 ÷ 18.6 is about 8 grams of gypsum, which also brings about 63 of calcium.

Then chloride. 50 ÷ 16.1 is about 3 grams of calcium chloride, which brings about 28 more calcium.

Check calcium. 63 + 28, plus the 10 to 20 already in Shoalhaven water, lands at about 100–110. Done.

So the answer is 8 g gypsum and 3 g calcium chloride in 30 litres. The ratio is 3:1 — crisp and hop-forward, as intended. For a hazy IPA you'd flip it, with mostly calcium chloride and a little gypsum.

Where to add the salts

Brew in a bag: stir everything into the full water volume before you heat it.

Mash and sparge: split the salts between mash water and sparge water in proportion to the volumes. Some brewers put all of the calcium in the mash for its pH effect. Either works. Be consistent so your results are repeatable.

Kettle additions: salts added to the boil still affect flavour, but not mash pH. That's handy for a late correction.

Weigh properly

At these quantities, a gram either way is a significant change. A small digital scale that reads to 0.1 g costs less than a tin of malt and is one of the best purchases an all grain brewer can make. Teaspoon measures are too inconsistent — salts vary a lot in density.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Chasing a famous city's profile. Historical brewing-city profiles are often averages of wells that varied enormously, and some included minerals the brewers then removed by boiling. Design for the beer, not the postcode.
  • High sulfate with high sodium. Together they taste harsh and minerally.
  • Adding salts to kits. The extract already has its minerals. Extra salts in a kit brew rarely help and can easily hurt.
  • Changing everything at once. Change one variable per batch and you'll know what made the difference.

Let software do the sums

Brewing software and online calculators do this arithmetic instantly once you enter your source water. Use them, but understand the logic above so you can sanity-check the output. If a calculator suggests 25 grams of anything for a home batch, something has been entered wrong.

Your water-building kit

  1. A scale that reads to 0.1 g — kitchen scales are not accurate at these weights.
  2. Gypsum for hoppy, dry beers.
  3. Calcium chloride for malty, full and hazy beers.
  4. Campden tablets to treat the chlorine first.
  5. A notebook, so a good profile can be brewed again.

Then taste

Numbers get you close. Your palate finishes the job. Brew the same recipe twice with different sulfate-to-chloride balances, taste them side by side, and you'll learn more about water than any chart can teach. And if you'd like a second opinion on a profile, bring it in.