Ask ten brewers on the South Coast what their water is like and you'll get ten answers, most of them wrong. The truth is fairly simple. If you're on town water anywhere around Nowra, your brewing water starts life soft, low in minerals, and disinfected with chlorine. All three facts matter, and only one of them is a problem.

Where it comes from

Most of the Shoalhaven is supplied by Shoalhaven Water, which draws from the Shoalhaven River system and treats it at plants including Bamarang, just west of Nowra. Treatment settles out sediment and colour, adjusts the pH so the water doesn't corrode pipes, disinfects it with chlorine, and adds fluoride.

None of that is bad news for beer. The sediment and colour removal is exactly what you want, the pH adjustment barely registers once malt is involved, and fluoride has no effect on brewing at all. The chlorine is the only part you need to do something about.

Soft water, and what that means

Shoalhaven Water describes the supply as soft, at around 50 mg/L of hardness measured as calcium carbonate. The Australian guideline value is 200, so we're at the gentle end of the scale.

For a brewer, hardness is mostly calcium and magnesium. Hardness of 50 mg/L as calcium carbonate works out to no more than about 20 mg/L of actual calcium, and usually less, because part of that hardness is magnesium. Most beer styles are happiest with something like 50 to 150 mg/L of calcium in the mash.

Calcium earns its place in four ways. It helps the mash enzymes do their job and nudges mash pH into the right range. It helps yeast clump together and drop out at the end of fermentation, which means clearer beer. It protects against beerstone building up in your gear. And it helps proteins drop out in the boil.

Soft water is usually low in alkalinity too, which is the other number that matters for all grain brewing. That's generally good news: high alkalinity is what makes pale beers taste dull and flabby, and it's the hardest thing to strip out of water. Adding minerals is easy. Taking them out is not.

What it's good for straight from the tap

If you brew from kits or extract, your water hardly matters beyond the chlorine. The extract was made from wort that already had the brewery's water chemistry in it. You're mostly just diluting it back out. Treat the chlorine, and Shoalhaven water is about as good a kit-brewing water as you'll find.

For all grain brewers, soft water is a gift for delicate pale lagers. The famous pilsners of Bohemia were brewed with some of the softest water in Europe, and a Czech-style pilsner, a Kölsch-style ale or a light lager needs very little added.

Where it needs help

Pale ales and IPAs are the beers that suffer most. Hop bitterness tastes soft and rounded in soft water, and the finish can be a little sweet. Adding gypsum brings sulfate, which sharpens the bitterness and dries out the finish. This is the single biggest improvement most local all grain brewers can make.

Hazy IPAs go the other way. They want a soft, full mouthfeel, so the extra calcium comes mostly from calcium chloride, with only a little gypsum.

Stouts and porters have a different problem. Dark malts are acidic, and with very little alkalinity in the water to balance them, a heavily roasted grist can push the mash pH too low. That shows up as a sharp, acrid roast character rather than smooth chocolate and coffee. A little calcium chloride helps, and if you measure pH you may need a gram or two of baking soda as well.

A starting point for a 23 litre batch

These are additions for roughly 30 litres of total brewing water — about what a 23 litre brew-in-a-bag batch uses. They assume Shoalhaven tap water and are meant as a first attempt, not a final answer.

Style Add to ~30 L What you're after
Pilsner or light lager Nothing, or 2 g calcium chloride Keep it soft and clean
Australian or American pale ale 6 g gypsum + 2 g calcium chloride Crisp, dry, hop-forward
West coast IPA 9 g gypsum + 2 g calcium chloride Firm bitterness, dry finish
Hazy IPA 3 g gypsum + 6 g calcium chloride Soft, full mouthfeel
Brown ale, porter or stout 2 g gypsum + 3 g calcium chloride, then check pH Smooth roast, no harshness

For brew-in-a-bag, stir the salts into the full volume before you heat it. If you mash and sparge separately, split them between the two in proportion to the volumes. Weigh them on a scale that reads to a tenth of a gram — kitchen scales aren't accurate at these weights.

Deal with the chlorine

This is the one change every Shoalhaven brewer should make, kit or all grain. Chlorine reacts with compounds in malt and yeast to make chlorophenols, which taste medicinal or plastic at tiny concentrations.

Because Shoalhaven Water uses chlorine rather than chloramine, you have several easy options. Fill your pot the night before and let it stand uncovered. Boil it for fifteen minutes. Or — fastest and most reliable — crush half a campden tablet into 25 to 30 litres and stir. The full story is in chlorine and chloramine: why your beer tastes like a pool.

Get the numbers for your own tap

Shoalhaven Water publishes monthly test results on its drinking water quality page. The figures move a little with season and rainfall, but never far enough to matter for a home brew. If you want to plug real numbers into brewing software, reading a council water report like a brewer walks through which lines to use.

On tank water the picture is different again: usually no chlorine, very soft, and sometimes slightly acidic. Treat it as close to distilled water and add calcium.

The short version

Kit brewers: treat the chlorine and stop worrying. All grain brewers: treat the chlorine, add calcium, and match the gypsum-to-chloride balance to the beer you're making. If you're not sure where your recipe sits, bring it in and we'll work out the additions across the counter.