There are four common types of fermenter for home brewing, and plenty of good beer comes out of all of them. The differences are in cost, cleaning, durability, safety and features.
Plastic buckets
The classic starter fermenter, usually food-grade HDPE with a lid, an airlock and a tap.
Good: - Cheap and light. - Wide opening — easy to clean, easy to add dry hops. - Robust; you can drop one without disaster.
Not so good: - Scratches. Plastic scratches easily, and scratches harbour bacteria. Never use abrasive cleaning pads. - Lid seals can leak, so the airlock may never bubble even when fermentation is going strong. Measure gravity rather than relying on the airlock. - Slightly permeable to oxygen over long periods, which matters if a beer sits in it for weeks.
Best for: new brewers, kit brewers, and anyone who wants a cheap second or third fermenter.
PET fermenters
Clear PET plastic, often conical, and in many cases rated for pressure. The FermZilla range is a popular example.
Good: - Pressure capable (on pressure-rated models), which opens up pressure fermentation, closed transfers and carbonating in the fermenter. - Transparent, so you can watch fermentation. - Conical models let you dump yeast and trub from the bottom or collect the yeast. - Lighter than glass, and much safer.
Not so good: - Can't take hot water. PET deforms above about 50 °C. Clean with warm, not hot, water. - Scratches, like any plastic. - More parts — valves, seals and fittings to clean and check. - Sunlight degrades PET over time. Keep it out of direct sun, which also protects the beer from going skunky.
Best for: brewers who want pressure fermentation and closed transfers without buying stainless.
Glass carboys
Traditional glass vessels with a narrow neck.
Good: - Completely inert — glass doesn't scratch, stain or hold smells. - Impermeable to oxygen, ideal for long ageing — wines, meads, sour beers.
Not so good: - Heavy, especially full. - Dangerous if dropped or cracked. A broken carboy causes serious cuts. Carry them in a crate or a harness, never by the neck, and never put hot liquid in them. - Hard to clean through a narrow neck.
Best for: wine, mead and long-aged beers. For everyday beer, most brewers now prefer PET or stainless. The same goes for demijohns in wine making.
Stainless steel
Stainless buckets and conicals, from simple to very elaborate.
Good: - Practically indestructible and won't scratch in normal use. - Takes hot water and strong cleaners. - Opaque, so no light damage. - Higher-end models offer thermowells, cooling jackets, pressure ratings and trub dumps.
Not so good: - Expensive. - Opaque — you can't see what's happening without opening it. - Heavier than plastic.
Best for: committed brewers who want a fermenter that lasts decades.
Features worth thinking about
- Size. For 23 litre batches you want about 30 litres of capacity. Fermentation produces a foamy head (krausen) that needs room.
- A tap or not? Taps make transfers easy but must be dismantled and cleaned every time. No tap means siphoning, which is fine.
- A thermowell — a tube into the middle of the beer for a temperature probe. Much more accurate than a probe taped to the outside.
- Fridge fit. If you plan to ferment in a fridge — and on the South Coast you should consider it — measure the fridge before you buy. Tall conicals often don't fit.
- Pressure rating, if you want pressure fermentation.
Looking after it
Whatever it's made of, a fermenter lasts much longer with a little care.
- Clean it straight after use. Rinse out the yeast cake while it's wet, then soak with a percarbonate cleaner. Dried krausen rings are much harder to shift.
- Use a soft cloth only on plastic and PET. No scourers, no stiff brushes.
- Dismantle the tap every time and clean the parts separately.
- Check seals and O-rings a couple of times a year, and replace any that are cracked, flattened or smelly.
- Store it dry, with the lid loose so it can air out. A sealed, damp fermenter grows mould.
- Don't store anything else in it. Fermenters pick up smells from whatever they hold.
A plastic fermenter that has started to look cloudy, scratched or stained inside has done its job. Replace it before it starts spoiling beer.
Our honest recommendation
- Starting out? A plastic bucket fermenter, ideally as part of a starter kit. It's cheap and makes good beer.
- Ready to upgrade? A pressure-capable PET fermenter gives you most of the benefits of stainless at a fraction of the price.
- Brewing for the long haul? Stainless will outlast everything else.
Whatever you choose, look after it: clean it gently, sanitise it properly, and replace it if it gets scratched. And if you'd like to see the options side by side, come in and we'll walk you through them.
What to look for in a first fermenter
- About 30 litres of capacity for a 23 litre batch.
- A lid or cap that seals properly, with an airlock or valve.
- A tap that comes apart for cleaning, if it has one.
- A size that fits your fridge, if you plan to control temperature.
- No scratches — inspect plastic fermenters before buying second-hand.