India pale ale has split into so many sub-styles that the name alone tells you very little. The three most common today are hazy, west coast and cold IPA. All three are hoppy and strong-ish. Almost everything else about them is different.
At a glance
| Hazy IPA | West coast IPA | Cold IPA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Look | Opaque, juicy | Clear, gold | Brilliantly clear, very pale |
| Body | Soft, full, smooth | Dry, lean | Very dry, crisp |
| Bitterness | Low to moderate | High | Moderate to high |
| Hop character | Juicy, tropical, stone fruit | Pine, resin, citrus | Bright, clean, fruity |
| Grist | Pale plus oats and wheat | Pale, little or no crystal | Pale plus rice or maize |
| Water | Chloride-forward | Sulfate-forward | Balanced to sulfate-forward |
| Yeast | Ester-forward ale yeast | Clean American ale yeast | Lager yeast, fermented warm |
Hazy IPA
Grist: pale or pilsner malt with 15 to 30 percent oats and wheat. These add proteins and beta-glucans that give body and help keep the haze in suspension.
Water: chloride-forward for a soft, round mouthfeel — something like 150 chloride to 75 sulfate. Mostly calcium chloride, a little gypsum.
Hops: very little bittering. Most of the hops go in the whirlpool and the dry hop, often in large quantities — 8 to 15 grams per litre in the dry hop. Many brewers dry hop during active fermentation to encourage biotransformation, then again at the end.
Yeast: an ester-forward strain that adds stone fruit and a soft texture. These strains often don't drop out well, which suits the style.
Fermentation: around 18 to 20 °C. Watch for hop creep after the dry hop — the gravity can keep falling.
The big risk: oxidation. Hazy IPAs turn brown, dull and muddy within weeks if oxygen gets in after fermentation. Kegging with closed transfers is a real advantage. If you bottle, be very careful, keep them cold and drink them fresh.
West coast IPA
Grist: mostly pale malt. Traditional versions use a little crystal; modern versions often use none, for a lighter colour and drier finish.
Mash: low, around 64 to 65 °C, for a highly fermentable wort and a dry finish, typically around 1.008 to 1.010.
Water: sulfate-forward, often 200 to 300 sulfate, to sharpen bitterness and dry the finish. Mostly gypsum.
Hops: a substantial bittering addition, typically for 50 to 70 IBU or more, plus late additions and a dry hop of around 4 to 8 grams per litre. Classic hop character is pine, resin and citrus.
Yeast: a clean, neutral American ale strain that lets the hops lead.
Finish: clear. Cold crash, consider fining, and package bright.
Cold IPA
The newest of the three, popularised by a brewery in Portland, Oregon around 2018. The idea is a hoppy beer with the crisp, clean, dry body of a lager — but without the weeks of lagering.
Grist: pale or pilsner malt with 20 to 30 percent rice or maize. These adjuncts lighten the body and colour and help the beer finish very dry.
Yeast: a lager strain fermented warm, around 15 to 18 °C, or a very clean ale yeast. The lager yeast gives a crisp, clean character; fermenting warm means it finishes in days rather than weeks.
Mash: low, for a highly fermentable wort.
Hops: moderate to high bitterness, and a generous late and dry hop, usually with bright, fruity varieties.
Finish: brilliantly clear, highly carbonated, and very dry. It should be refreshing rather than heavy.
What actually changes most
If you take a single base recipe and want to move it between these styles, these are the levers that matter, in order:
- Yeast — juicy ale strain, clean ale strain or lager strain.
- Water — chloride-forward or sulfate-forward.
- Grist adjuncts — oats and wheat for hazy, rice or maize for cold, neither for west coast.
- Hop timing — late and dry for hazy, a firm bittering addition for west coast.
- Mash temperature — low for west coast and cold IPA, moderate for hazy.
One base, three IPAs
Here's how one 23 litre IPA of about 1.062 might be adapted for each style. The quantities are a sketch to show the differences, not a finished recipe — enter them into your software and adjust for your system.
| Hazy | West coast | Cold IPA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pale or pilsner malt | 5.0 kg | 6.3 kg | 5.0 kg |
| Oats and wheat | 1.0 kg oats + 0.5 kg wheat | — | — |
| Rice or flaked maize | — | — | 1.5 kg |
| Light crystal | — | 150 g | — |
| Mash | 67 °C | 64 °C | 64 °C |
| Bitterness | 25–35 IBU | 55–65 IBU | 40–50 IBU |
| Whirlpool hops | 120 g | 60 g | 80 g |
| Dry hop | 200–250 g, split | 120–150 g | 150 g |
| Water (≈30 L) | 2 g gypsum + 7 g calcium chloride | 10 g gypsum + 1 g calcium chloride | 6 g gypsum + 2 g calcium chloride |
| Yeast | Juicy, ester-forward ale | Clean American ale | Lager yeast at 15–18 °C |
Notice that the hop varieties can be identical across all three. The yeast, the water and the grist are what turn the same hops into three very different beers.
Hops for each style
Australian hops suit all three. Galaxy and Vic Secret are natural in a hazy or a cold IPA. For a west coast IPA, combine a resinous hop for bitterness and backbone with Galaxy or Eclipse for citrus on top. The Australian hops guide has more detail.
All three share one rule
Whichever IPA you brew, hop aroma is fragile. Use fresh hops, keep oxygen away from the finished beer, store it cold and drink it within a month or two. If you'd like help building a recipe for any of them, bring your plans in and we'll talk it through.
Three IPAs, three shopping lists
- Hazy: oats and wheat, a juicy yeast, calcium chloride, big late hops.
- West coast: pale malt, a clean yeast, gypsum, firm bitterness.
- Cold IPA: rice or maize, lager yeast fermented warm, crisp and dry.
- For all three: fresh hops, and as little oxygen as possible after fermentation.