A recipe says you'll hit 1.052. You hit 1.044. The beer will still be fine — slightly weaker and lighter — but the missing points are frustrating, and if they move around from batch to batch, they make it impossible to brew the same beer twice.

Three kinds of efficiency

The word gets used for three different things, and knowing which one you're short on tells you where to look.

Conversion efficiency — how much of the starch in the grain the mash turned into sugar. A healthy mash converts 95 percent or more.

Lauter efficiency — how much of that sugar you got out of the grain and into the kettle. This is where sparging, or squeezing the bag, comes in.

Brewhouse efficiency — the bottom line: how much of the grain's potential ended up in the fermenter. This includes wort left behind in the kettle and the mash tun. It's the number recipe software asks for.

Most home setups land between 65 and 80 percent brewhouse efficiency. A consistent 70 is far more useful than a number that bounces between 62 and 78.

Step 1: check conversion

Near the end of the mash, take a small sample of liquid, cool it, and measure its gravity. Brewing software or an online calculator will tell you what the first runnings should read for your grist and water volume if conversion is complete. If you're well short, the problem is in the mash.

Common causes of poor conversion:

  • Crush too coarse — the most frequent culprit by far. The crush guide covers what to ask for.
  • Mash pH out of range — see mash pH explained.
  • Dough balls — dry clumps that never get wet inside.
  • Mash too short or too cold — an hour at 64 to 68 °C is standard. Some grists need longer.
  • Old or poorly stored grain.

Step 2: check what you rinsed out

If conversion is fine, the sugar is being left behind in the grain.

  • Not enough sparge water. Too little rinse leaves sugar behind.
  • Sparging too fast. With a continuous fly sparge, rushing creates channels the water runs through without rinsing the grain bed evenly.
  • A stuck or slow sparge that you cut short.
  • Not stirring before draining. If you batch sparge, stir the grain thoroughly after adding sparge water, let it settle, then drain.
  • Not squeezing the bag. In brew in a bag, the bag holds a surprising amount of sugary wort.

Step 3: find the wort you left behind

This is the hidden one. A system that leaves two litres in the mash tun and two litres in the kettle loses around 15 percent of a 23 litre batch, however good the mash was.

  • Mash tun dead space under the false bottom or below the tap.
  • Kettle losses — wort left in the hop and protein sludge.
  • Grain absorption — grain holds about 1 litre per kilo in a mash tun, less if you squeeze a bag.

You can reduce these losses by tilting the kettle or using a hop spider, but often the better answer is simply to set your software's equipment profile to match reality. Losses you plan for aren't a problem.

Step 4: check your measurements

Before changing your process, make sure the numbers are real.

  • Temperature correction. Hydrometers are calibrated for one temperature, usually 20 °C. A hot sample reads low. Cool it, or apply a correction.
  • Unmixed wort. If you've topped up with water, the wort stratifies. Stir thoroughly before sampling.
  • Volume errors. If the markings on your vessel are out by a litre, your efficiency calculation is too. Calibrate them once with a jug.
  • Refractometer readings after fermentation starts. They need a correction for alcohol. The hydrometer and refractometer guide explains.

A worked example

Numbers make this concrete. Say your recipe has 5 kg of pale malt and you collect 23 litres in the fermenter at 1.046.

  • Pale malt has a potential of roughly 300 gravity points per kilo per litre. Five kilos therefore has a potential of 5 × 300 = 1,500 points-litres.
  • What you actually got: 46 points × 23 litres = 1,058 points-litres.
  • Brewhouse efficiency = 1,058 ÷ 1,500 = about 70 percent.

Now take the pre-boil reading too. If you had 28 litres in the kettle at 1.040, that's 40 × 28 = 1,120 points-litres — about 75 percent of potential before the boil. The difference between 75 and 70 percent is wort left in the kettle. If pre-boil was already low, the loss happened earlier, in the mash or the sparge.

Taking readings at each stage — first runnings, pre-boil, into the fermenter — tells you where the points went, not just that they went.

What different methods typically achieve

Method Typical brewhouse efficiency
Brew in a bag, no sparge 65–75%
Brew in a bag with a dunk or pour-over sparge 70–78%
Batch sparge in an esky 70–78%
Fly sparge, done slowly 75–85%
All-in-one recirculating system 70–80%

These are ranges, not targets. If your setup sits in its range and the number is consistent, your process is fine.

Fixes, in order of impact

  1. Get the crush right for your system.
  2. Fix mash pH, especially for pale beers.
  3. Stir thoroughly at mash-in and before every drain.
  4. Use enough sparge water and don't rush it.
  5. Plan for your losses in your software instead of chasing them.
  6. Measure carefully and take readings at the same points every brew.

Chasing the number is optional

Brewers sometimes push efficiency up at the cost of beer quality — over-sparging pulls tannins, and an ultra-fine crush brings stuck sparges. A few kilos of extra grain cost much less than a batch of astringent beer. Aim for consistency first. Once your efficiency is stable, set your recipes to it and brew.

If the numbers still don't add up, bring your brew-day notes in — gravities, volumes and temperatures — and we'll work through them with you.