It's one of the most common complaints we hear across the counter, and one of the easiest to fix. The beer looks fine, smells mostly fine, but there's something medicinal in it — antiseptic, sticking plaster, or a plastic edge that gets stronger as the glass warms up.
What's happening
Town water is disinfected with chlorine, or with chloramine, a more stable compound made from chlorine and ammonia. Both react with phenols — natural compounds from malt and yeast — to form chlorophenols.
Chlorophenols have an extraordinarily low taste threshold. People can pick them up at a few parts per billion, which is a few drops in an Olympic pool. Fermentation doesn't remove them, ageing doesn't fade them, and once they're in the beer, nothing gets them out.
Which one is in your tap?
Shoalhaven Water disinfects with chlorine. That's the good news, because chlorine is the easier of the two to remove. Some other Australian water utilities use chloramine, so if you're brewing elsewhere or have just moved here, check with your local supplier.
If you're on tank or bore water, you probably have neither. Skip to the section on other causes.
Removing chlorine
Chlorine is volatile, so you have several options.
- Let it stand. Fill your pot or fermenter the night before and leave it uncovered. Most of the chlorine gasses off overnight.
- Boil it. Fifteen minutes at a rolling boil drives chlorine off. All grain brewers boiling for an hour get this for free in the kettle — but any chlorinated water in the mash has already done its damage, so treat it before mashing.
- Carbon filtration. A good activated carbon filter removes chlorine if the water passes through slowly enough.
- Campden tablets. The fastest and most reliable option, and the one we recommend.
Campden tablets: the two-minute fix
Campden tablets are potassium or sodium metabisulphite. In water they neutralise chlorine and chloramine almost instantly.
One tablet treats about 75 litres, so half a tablet crushed into 25 to 30 litres covers a typical batch. Crush it, stir it in, and give it a minute or two. That's it. At this dose the leftover sulphite is negligible and has no effect on the yeast or the flavour.
They're the same tablets wine makers use, so you'll find them with the wine ingredients. A packet lasts a long time.
Treat all of it
The most common way people get caught is the top-up. Kit brewers carefully treat the water they mix the kit with, then top the fermenter up to 23 litres straight from the hose. Treat every drop that goes into the beer — mash water, sparge water, kit water and top-up water.
Other causes of the same flavour
If you treat your water and the plastic or medicinal note persists, look here next.
Bleach-based sanitisers. Chlorine bleach left on equipment does the same job as chlorinated water. Either rinse thoroughly with treated water or, better, switch to a no-rinse acid sanitiser. The sanitising guide covers the options.
Wild yeast and bacteria. Many wild yeasts produce phenols that taste like cloves, smoke or band-aids. If the flavour came on gradually or gets worse in the bottle, suspect an infection and go back over your sanitation.
The yeast itself. Some strains make clove-like phenols on purpose. A hefeweizen or a Belgian ale is supposed to taste spicy. In a pale ale it's a fault, and the cause is usually the wrong yeast or a stressed ferment.
The off-flavours diagnostic chart helps tell these apart.
Chlorine-proof every batch
- Crush half a campden tablet into 25–30 litres of brewing water and stir.
- Treat top-up water for kits as well as mash water.
- Sanitise with a no-rinse acid sanitiser, not bleach.
- If the flavour persists, look at sanitation and wild yeast next.