When a beer tastes wrong, it's tempting to change everything for the next batch. Don't. Name the flavour first. Once you know what you're tasting, the cause is usually obvious — and so is the fix.
How to taste for faults
- Pour into a clean glass that has been rinsed well — detergent residue causes its own faults.
- Let it warm a little. Many faults hide when beer is ice cold.
- Smell first, with short sniffs. Then cover the glass with your hand, swirl, and smell again.
- Taste, holding the beer in your mouth, then swallow and notice the aftertaste.
- Notice when the fault appeared. Was it there at bottling? Did it develop in the bottle? Is it in every bottle or only some? The timing is often the biggest clue.
The chart
| You taste or smell | Compound | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Green apple, fresh-cut pumpkin | Acetaldehyde | Packaged too early; yeast stopped short; underpitching | Leave on the yeast longer at a comfortable temperature; pitch enough yeast |
| Butter, butterscotch, slick feel | Diacetyl | Packaged too early; cold lager ferment; bacterial infection | Diacetyl rest; more time; check sanitation if it comes with sourness |
| Cooked corn, cabbage, tinned vegetables | DMS | Pilsner-heavy grist; covered or weak boil; slow cooling | Vigorous uncovered boil; chill quickly |
| Medicinal, band-aid, plastic, antiseptic | Chlorophenols | Chlorinated water; bleach sanitiser not rinsed | Campden tablets; no-rinse acid sanitiser |
| Clove, smoke, pepper (unwanted) | Phenols | Wild yeast infection; wrong yeast strain | Sanitation; check the yeast |
| Hot, solvent, nail polish remover | Fusel alcohols, ethyl acetate | Fermented too warm; underpitched; stressed yeast | Temperature control from day one; adequate pitch |
| Banana, bubblegum (unwanted) | Esters | Fermented too warm; underpitched | Cooler fermentation; adequate pitch |
| Wet cardboard, paper | Oxidation | Oxygen after fermentation; old beer | Avoid splashing when packaging; purge kegs; drink fresh |
| Sherry, honey, toffee in a light beer | Oxidation (advanced) | Long or warm storage with oxygen | As above; store cold |
| Skunky, like a fox or cannabis | Lightstruck (MBT) | Light hitting hops in the beer | Brown bottles; keep out of sun and fluorescent light |
| Metallic, blood, coins | Metals | Unprotected iron or poorly passivated metal; some water sources | Stainless or food-grade gear; check water |
| Dry, puckering, like stewed tea | Tannins (astringency) | Over-sparging; mash or sparge pH too high; steeping grains too hot | Control pH; stop sparging at about 1.010; steep below 77 °C |
| Sour, vinegar | Lactic or acetic acid | Bacterial infection | Sanitation; replace scratched plastic |
| Rotten egg, struck match | Sulphur compounds | Some yeasts, especially lagers; nutrient-poor wort | Conditioning time; yeast nutrient |
| Meaty, soy sauce, rubbery | Yeast autolysis | Beer left too long on dead yeast, especially warm | Package sooner; don't store on the yeast cake |
| Cidery, thin, winey | Too much simple sugar | Dextrose-heavy kit recipe | Use malt or brew enhancer instead of sugar |
| Grassy, vegetal, freshly cut hay | Plant material | Old hops; very long dry hop | Fresh hops; 2–4 day dry hop |
| Soapy | Fatty acids; detergent | Dirty glassware; long time on yeast | Rinse glasses well; package sooner |
| Cheesy, sweaty socks | Isovaleric acid | Old, oxidised hops; some infections | Store hops cold and sealed; sanitation |
| Vomit, rancid butter | Butyric acid | Bacterial contamination, often in poorly controlled kettle souring | Pre-acidify sour wort; keep oxygen out |
| Harsh, coarse bitterness | Various | High water pH; very high hop rates; certain hops | Control mash pH; adjust hop schedule |
The common clusters
Faults rarely appear alone. Spotting a cluster points straight at a cause.
Hot + banana + butter + green apple — a stressed, warm, rushed fermentation. This is by far the most common pattern around Nowra in summer. Control the temperature, pitch enough yeast, and give it time. The fermentation temperature guide is the place to start.
Sour + gushing + gets worse over weeks — an infection. Sanitation, starting with anything plastic that might be scratched.
Medicinal + plastic, in every batch — water. Campden tablets.
Cardboard + dull hops + darkening colour — oxygen after fermentation. Look at how you transfer and package.
Skunky, only in some bottles — light. Check which bottles were clear or green, or stored in the light.
Faults that age out, and faults that don't
Can improve with time: - Diacetyl and acetaldehyde — if there's still healthy yeast in the beer. - Sulphur — usually fades in a few weeks. - Harshness in strong beers — softens over months. - Some green, young flavours generally.
Won't improve: - Chlorophenols. - Fusel alcohols. - Infection — it usually gets worse. - Oxidation — always gets worse. - Lightstruck flavour. - Astringency, largely.
If a fault won't improve, there's no point waiting. Learn from it, change the cause, and brew again.
Faults by stage
Sometimes it's easier to work forwards through the process than backwards from the flavour. Here's where each fault usually starts.
Water. Chlorine causes medicinal chlorophenols. High alkalinity causes harsh bitterness and astringency in pale beers. Metals cause metallic tastes.
Mash and sparge. A mash pH that's too high pulls tannins, giving astringency. Over-sparging does the same. A mash that's too hot leaves a beer sweet and heavy rather than faulty.
Boil. A weak or covered boil leaves DMS — cooked corn. Old or poorly stored hops bring cheesy or grassy notes.
Cooling. Slow cooling also encourages DMS, and gives bacteria a warm window to get established before the yeast takes over.
Pitching. Too little yeast, or yeast pitched into warm wort, sets up esters, fusels and diacetyl.
Fermentation. Temperature is the big one: too warm brings fusels, esters and solvent; a sudden drop can stall the yeast and leave diacetyl and acetaldehyde.
Conditioning. Packaging too early leaves green apple and butter. Leaving beer too long on dead yeast in warm conditions brings meaty, rubbery autolysis.
Packaging. Splashing finished beer causes oxidation. Dirty bottles cause infection in some bottles but not others. Uneven priming causes some bottles to be flat and others to gush.
Storage. Warmth speeds up staling. Light causes skunkiness within hours. Time eventually oxidises every beer.
Is it the glass, the fridge or the beer?
Before blaming the beer, rule out the serving.
- Glassware that's been washed with detergent and not rinsed well leaves a film that kills the head and can taste soapy or greasy.
- Beer that's too cold hides aroma and flavour; let it warm a few degrees before judging it.
- A dirty tap or beer line on a keg system can add buttery, sour or stale flavours to an otherwise clean beer — the beer line guide explains.
- Strong smells in the fridge can creep into kegs and open bottles.
Pour a bottle into a freshly rinsed glass at about 8 to 10 °C. If the fault is still there, it's in the beer.
Learning the flavours
Off-flavour training kits — small vials of individual compounds you add to a neutral commercial beer — are the quickest way to learn what each fault tastes like. Some brew clubs run tasting nights with them. If you can't get a kit, the next best thing is tasting deliberately: compare a fresh pale ale with one left on a sunny windowsill for an hour, or a young lager with one aged for a couple of months, and you'll learn lightstruck and oxidised flavours faster than any description can teach.
When it's a whole batch versus some bottles
- Every bottle tastes the same: the problem happened before packaging — in the brew, the fermentation or the water.
- Only some bottles: the problem happened at or after bottling — dirty bottles, uneven priming, light exposure, or a seal that didn't hold.
Bring it in
The fastest way to learn off-flavours is to taste them with someone who knows them. Bring a bottle into the shop and we'll taste it with you, tell you what we think is going on and suggest the fix. It's one of our favourite parts of the job.
The five fixes that solve most off-flavours
- Control fermentation temperature, especially in the first three days.
- Pitch enough healthy yeast.
- Clean, then sanitise, everything that touches cooled wort.
- Treat chlorinated water with campden tablets.
- Keep oxygen and light away from finished beer.