Bottling is where most home brewers start, and plenty stay there happily. Kegging is the upgrade people talk about most. Both make excellent beer. The real differences are in time, upfront cost and convenience.
What you need for each
Bottling: - About thirty 750 mL bottles, or sixty-odd stubbies, for a 23 litre batch — reusable for years. - Crown seals and a capper, or PET bottles with screw caps. - Priming sugar or carbonation drops. - A bottling wand and a bottle rinser or tree.
Kegging: - One or more kegs — 19 litre kegs are the standard home-brew size. - A CO₂ cylinder and a regulator. - Gas and beer lines, disconnects and a tap. - A fridge to keep the keg cold, because carbonation and serving both depend on temperature.
Money: upfront
Bottling is cheap to start. Bottles are often free — rinse out and save your commercial long necks — and a capper and crown seals don't cost much.
Kegging needs a real upfront spend: kegs, gas cylinder, regulator, lines, tap and a fridge. A second-hand fridge reduces the bill a lot. Ask us and we'll price up a setup that suits your space.
Money: per batch
This is where people expect kegging to win, and it mostly doesn't.
- Bottling, per batch: crown seals and priming sugar. Small.
- Kegging, per batch: CO₂ for carbonating and serving. Also small — a cylinder of gas carbonates and serves a good number of kegs if your system doesn't leak.
The running costs are similar. Kegging doesn't pay for itself in dollars in any reasonable time. What it saves is time.
Time: per batch
This is the big difference.
| Bottling | Kegging | |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning and sanitising | Thirty bottles, one by one | One keg |
| Filling | Thirty bottles plus capping | One transfer |
| Typical time | 1.5–2 hours | 20–30 minutes |
| Ready to drink | 2–3 weeks to carbonate | A few days to a week |
Brew once a month and kegging saves you roughly 15 to 20 hours a year. For many brewers, that's what decides it.
A simple way to decide on cost
If you want to put a number on it:
Payback in batches = setup cost ÷ (bottling cost per batch − kegging cost per batch)
Because the per-batch costs are so close, the result is usually a very large number. That's the honest answer: decide on kegging for time, convenience and beer quality, not to save money.
Beer quality
Kegging advantages: - Less oxygen exposure if you purge the keg with CO₂ and transfer carefully — a real benefit for hoppy beers. - Precise carbonation you can adjust at any time. - No yeast sediment in the glass. - Faster turnaround from fermenter to glass.
Bottling advantages: - Bottle conditioning adds a little complexity and protects against oxidation, because the yeast scavenges oxygen. - Ageing — strong beers, stouts and Belgians often improve for months in the bottle. - Portability — take bottles to a barbecue, give them away, enter them in competitions.
Space
Bottles take up shelf space and need somewhere stable to condition at 18 to 22 °C. Kegging needs a fridge, which is a bigger footprint but holds everything in one place.
Your first keg: what to expect
- Clean and sanitise the keg, including the posts and dip tube.
- Transfer the beer gently into the keg, leaving the sediment behind in the fermenter.
- Seal the lid, pressurise to around 30 psi to seat the lid seal, and purge the headspace a few times by lifting the pressure relief valve.
- Put it in the fridge, connect the gas at your carbonation pressure — about 12 psi at 4 °C for most ales — and leave it for about a week.
- Pour. The first glass or two will be cloudy with sediment from the bottom of the keg. After that it clears.
Most first-keg problems are foam — usually from too much pressure, warm beer or a short beer line — or a slow leak. The carbonation guide and the CO₂ guide cover both.
The middle path
Plenty of brewers do both: keg the everyday beers, bottle a few from each keg for sharing using a counter-pressure filler or a simple bottling gun, and bottle strong beers for ageing.
The verdict
- Brew occasionally, enjoy the process, like giving beer away: bottle.
- Brew regularly, value your weekends, drink mostly at home: keg.
- Can't decide: start with bottles, and switch when bottling day starts to feel like a chore.
A basic kegging setup
- One or two 19 litre kegs.
- A CO2 cylinder, filled or on swap.
- A regulator with gauges.
- Gas and beer lines, disconnects and a tap.
- A fridge to keep it all cold — second-hand is fine.