Learning to taste fermentation by-products is one of the fastest ways to improve as a brewer. Almost every "my beer tastes a bit off" problem traces back to something the yeast did, and the yeast almost always did it because of conditions we gave it.

Esters: fruit, wanted and unwanted

What they taste like: fruit. Banana, pear, apple, strawberry, bubblegum, rose.

Where they come from: yeast produces esters as it ferments, especially while it's growing quickly early on. Different strains make different amounts and kinds.

Esters are a fault in some styles and essential in others. A hefeweizen without banana isn't a hefeweizen. An English bitter is meant to have gentle fruit. A clean pale lager should have almost none.

More esters come from:

  • Warmer fermentation — the biggest single factor.
  • Underpitching — the yeast has to grow more.
  • High-gravity wort.
  • Low oxygen at pitching, for some strains.
  • Open fermentation and wide, shallow vessels, compared with tall closed ones.

Fewer esters come from: cooler, steady fermentation, an adequate pitch, and fermenting under a little pressure, which suppresses ester formation.

Diacetyl: butter and butterscotch

What it tastes like: butter, butterscotch, buttered popcorn. It can also feel slick on the tongue. Some people are very sensitive to it; others barely notice.

Where it comes from: yeast releases a precursor into the beer during fermentation, which turns into diacetyl. Healthy yeast then reabsorbs the diacetyl and breaks it down — but only if it's given time and warmth at the end of fermentation.

Common causes:

  • Packaging too early, before the yeast has cleaned up.
  • Lager yeast at low temperatures, which works slowly.
  • Yeast that drops out early, as some English strains do.
  • Underpitching and stressed yeast.
  • Bacterial infection, particularly some lactic acid bacteria — in which case the diacetyl often comes with sourness.
  • Hop creep after dry hopping, which restarts fermentation and makes more.

The fix: a diacetyl rest. When fermentation is about three-quarters done, let the beer warm a few degrees — lagers to around 16 to 18 °C, ales to 20 to 22 °C — and hold it there for two to three days before cooling or packaging.

A quick test: put a small sample in a sealed jar, warm it in hot water to about 60 °C for 15 minutes, then cool it and smell. Warming converts the precursor into diacetyl. If the sample smells buttery, the beer needs more time on the yeast.

Fusel alcohols: hot and solvent

What they taste like: hot, harsh and solvent-like, with a burning sensation, sometimes like nail polish remover or paint thinner. Beers with a lot of fusels can taste stronger than they are and are notorious for headaches.

Where they come from: yeast makes them when it's stressed, especially when it's working hot and fast.

Common causes:

  • High fermentation temperatures — by far the most common cause on the South Coast in summer.
  • Underpitching.
  • Poor yeast nutrition, particularly in sugar-heavy worts.

The fix is prevention. Fusels don't age out. Control the temperature, especially in the first three days — see keeping fermentation cool.

Acetaldehyde: green apple

What it tastes like: freshly cut green apple, sometimes pumpkin or latex paint.

Where it comes from: an intermediate step on the way to alcohol. Healthy yeast converts it to ethanol at the end of fermentation.

Common causes: packaging too early, yeast that stops working before it's finished, underpitching, and oxygen getting into the finished beer. Like diacetyl, it's cleaned up by giving the beer time on healthy yeast at a comfortable temperature.

Sulphur: rotten eggs and struck matches

What it smells like: rotten eggs, struck matches, or a general sulphury whiff.

Where it comes from: many lager strains, and some ale strains, produce sulphur compounds during fermentation. Stressed yeast and nutrient-poor worts produce more.

The good news: most of it escapes with the CO₂ during fermentation, and what's left usually fades with a few weeks of conditioning or lagering. A sulphury lager at two weeks is normal. A sulphury lager at two months is a problem — check for yeast health and infection.

Phenols: clove, smoke and medicine

What they taste like: clove, pepper, smoke, or — less pleasantly — medicinal, plastic and band-aid.

Where they come from: some yeast strains — wheat beer and Belgian strains in particular — make clove-like phenols on purpose. Wild yeast often make smoky or medicinal ones. And chlorinated water produces chlorophenols, the medicinal ones.

If you didn't choose a phenolic yeast and your beer tastes of clove or band-aid, check your water treatment (chlorine guide) and your sanitation.

A quick reference

Flavour Compound Usual cause Control
Banana, pear, bubblegum Esters Warm or underpitched ferment Cooler ferment, right pitch
Butter, butterscotch Diacetyl Packaged too early Diacetyl rest, more time
Hot, solvent Fusels Hot, stressed ferment Temperature control from day one
Green apple Acetaldehyde Packaged too early More time on healthy yeast
Rotten egg Sulphur Lager yeast, stress Conditioning time
Clove, smoke, band-aid Phenols Yeast strain, wild yeast, chlorine Strain choice, sanitation, campden

A worked temperature schedule

Here's how a temperature plan for a clean American-style pale ale controls most of the compounds above at once.

  • Days 1 to 3: hold at 17 to 18 °C. This is when the yeast grows fastest and makes most of its esters and fusels. Keeping it cool here does more for flavour than anything else.
  • Days 4 to 6: let it rise to 20 °C. Most of the sugar is gone and the yeast is less likely to make unwanted compounds. The extra warmth keeps it active as fermentation slows.
  • Days 6 to 8: hold at 20 to 21 °C. This is effectively a diacetyl rest. The yeast reabsorbs diacetyl and acetaldehyde and finishes the last few gravity points.
  • Check the gravity — steady for two to three days — and do the warm-sample diacetyl test.
  • Then cold crash and package.

The same shape works for most ales with the numbers shifted to suit the strain. Lagers follow the same logic at lower temperatures: around 10 to 12 °C for the main fermentation, a rise to 16 to 18 °C for the rest, then weeks of cold conditioning.

Training your palate

The best way to learn these is to taste them deliberately. Taste your beer at every stage — at pitching, during fermentation, at packaging and over the following weeks. Note what changes. Taste commercial examples of styles where these compounds are meant to be present: banana in a hefeweizen, clove in a Belgian, a touch of diacetyl in some English bitters.

And if you're not sure what you're tasting, bring a bottle in. We'll taste it with you and tell you what we think is going on.